Factors which Affect Estrogen Exposure SummaryIn short, women can be at increased risk for breast cancer when they are exposed to higher levels of estrogen. This may occur through increased number of menstrual cycles or particular patterns of estrogen metabolism which allow for elevated levels or more potent estrogens to be formed. Higher estrogen exposure may also be induced artificially, with hormonal drugs in the form of birth control pills, injections, vaginal rings, IUDs and patches, or hormone replacement therapy (HRT). Surgical removal of a woman’s ovaries before menopause lowers her exposure to estrogen and decreases her risk.
(Underlined
words can be found by clicking HERE
FOR THE GLOSSARY,
which will open in a new window, or by clicking on the word to see the definition in a separate popup window.) Chapter 5:Breast Maturity & Breast Cancer Risk
At birth, you have a small amount of breast tissue,
Type 1 lobules, which are very immature and are known
as TDLUs (terminal ductal lobular units). Ductal cancers
which account for 85% of all breast cancers are known
to arise in Type 1 lobules. An infant’s breast
tissue may be stimulated by the mother’s hormones
present in the infant at birth. This can cause a milky
secretion called “witch’s milk”
for a short time after birth. At puberty, in response
to the cyclic elevations of estrogen and progesterone,
the breasts start to develop further, and some Type
1 lobules are matured into Type 2 lobules, which have
more ductules per lobular unit.2 lobules are where
up to 15% of all breast cancers start. By the end
of puberty, about 75% of breast tissue is Type 1 lobules
and 25% are Type 2. Not only do these lobules look different anatomically, but they grow differently. For example, Type 1 and 2 lobules copy their DNA faster than Type 3 lobules. The faster DNA is copied, the higher the risk of mutations or cancer cells forming. Actual photomicrographs of human breast lobules:
The principle of breast cancer risk relating to
lobule maturity can explain other well-documented
breast cancer risks as well. (Underlined
words can be found by clicking HERE
FOR THE GLOSSARY,
which will open in a new window, or by clicking on the word to see the definition in a separate popup window.) Chapter 6:Age and Length of Carcinogen Exposure
& Breast Cancer Risk
|
![]() |
A woman may become pregnant after a cancer cell has
formed in her breast, a cell which may have been dormant
for many years. Early in pregnancy, even before the
embryo has implanted in the womb, the woman’s
estrogen levels rise, and this may stimulate the dormant
cancer cell to grow into a clinically detectable cancer.
This accounts for the slight, temporary
increase in breast cancer risk in the post-partum
woman over age 25.
But sometimes the dormant cancer may grow into detectable
cancer while the woman is still pregnant, a situation
known as gestational breast cancer. Often, doctors
recommend “therapeutic abortion” so that,
by terminating the pregnancy as soon as possible,
the most aggressive cancer therapy can be given to
maximize the woman’s chances of survival. However,
many decades of clinical data have shown the reverse
to be true: A woman’s chances of survival are
maximized if she carries the pregnancy to term. Strong
doses of chemotherapy can even be given without harm
to the baby, as long as the pregnancy has gone beyond
the first trimester. Even in cases where a premenopausal
woman has previously been treated for breast cancer,
having a full-term pregnancy decreases the risk of
recurrence of the cancer.
Sometimes, a pregnant woman learns that the child
she is carrying has a developmental problem that will
not allow him or her to survive long after birth,
and abortion or premature induction of labor will
be recommended. However, carrying that child to term
will decrease the mother’s future risk of breast
cancer, while abortion will increase her risk. There
are perinatal hospice programs, organizations that
specialize in adoption services for children with
such disabilities as Down’s Syndrome, and organizations
which support the families of these infants.
High doses of radiation are known to increase
breast cancer risk. Exposure to radiation from the
atomic bomb at Hiroshima caused increased
breast cancer incidence, especially in women exposed
as teenagers, when their breast cells were very immature.
Repeated x-ray exposure for treatment of tuberculosis,
postpartum mastitis, chest acne and monitoring treatment
for scoliosis increases risk. Life
saving radiation treatment to the chest of young women
with Hodgkin’s disease increases
breast cancer risk.
The amount of radiation needed to cause breast cancer
is from 100 to 450 rads, (a rad is a radiation dosage
measurement). Fortunately, with today’s screening
mammograms, breasts are exposed to only 0.25 rads.
Therefore, it is estimated that a woman would need
at least 400 mammograms to increase
her breast cancer risk at all.
Two very common ways women are exposed to hormonal
therapy are through contraceptive medications and
hormone replacement therapy (HRT) after the .
It is now well established that birth control medications
(contraceptive steroids) increase breast cancer risk,
especially if they are taken before the first full-term
pregnancy, when breast cells are still immature. Birth
control pills are very commonly used by young women.
In one study, women who took birth control pills before
the age of 20 had a more than ten-fold increased risk
of breast cancer. The longer the pill is used, the
higher the risk. Contraceptive steroids increase risk
whether they are given orally (i.e., ‘the pill’),
by injection (e.g., Depo-Provera), implantation, through
the skin with a patch, intravaginally with a ring
(e.g., Nuva Ring) or with an intrauterine device (IUD).
Even ‘low dose’ estrogen pills have been
associated with higher breast cancer risk.
The so called “emergency contraceptives”
or “morning after pills” (e.g., “Plan
B”) consist of a very high dose of the same
synthetic progestational steroid as found in ordinary
oral contraceptives. Although “ only”
contraceptives (e.g., Depo Provera) are associated
with increased breast cancer risk, “emergency
contraceptives” are intended to be taken only
on rare occasions. It is unlikely that such occasional
use would result in any significant increase in breast
cancer risk. Even though these pills can act by inducing
very early abortions, do not rise to very
high levels until after the second week of pregnancy.
Therefore, abortions induced by “emergency contraceptives”
also would not be expected to add significantly to
a woman’s breast cancer risk.
The effect of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) on
the risk of breast cancer depends on the type of formulation.
Remember (Chapter 4) that estrogen’s effect
as a depends upon the presence of some .
After the menopause, when the ovaries stop making
estrogen and progesterone, if a woman takes an ‘estrogen
only’ form of HRT (usually a mixture of naturally
derived estrogens), the absence of progesterone from
her ovaries means there is little or no increase in
breast cancer risk. However, estrogen alone acts as
a mitogen in the uterus and increases the risk of
uterine cancer, which is why it is typically prescribed
for women who have had a hysterectomy. When the uterus
is still present, most doctors have prescribed combination
HRT (e.g., the “Prem-Pro” regimen), which
also contains a synthetic progestin. Combination HRT
decreases the risk of uterine cancer, but increases
the risk of breast cancer, as do contraceptive steroids.
Importantly, the effects of estrogen acting as a mitogen
are apparent much sooner among older women, who may
have undetectable, precancerous abnormalities in their
breasts. Use of HRT can stimulate such abnormal cells
to grow into clinically apparent cancer, sometimes
within a matter of months. This was recently demonstrated
on a massive scale with a substantial drop in breast
cancer incidence among postmenopausal American women
in 2003-4, following a sharp decline in combination
HRT use in 2002-2003. Such dramatic effects with even
the natural estrogens of HRT echo earlier findings
of the risk-increasing effect of the potent synthetic
estrogen DES. DES has even been found to increase
the breast cancer risk of women whose mothers took
the medication during their pregnancy, as well as
that of the mothers themselves.
Like other patient medications, estrogenic hormones
and drugs, used judiciously and for short periods,
can be beneficial. With long term use, they can significantly
increase breast cancer risk. There are effective alternatives
to the use of these medications which do not increase
breast cancer risk. These are discussed in Chapter
14.
Breast-feeding decreases risk of breast cancer, because it results in some menstrual cycles without an estrogen peak before ovulation and missed menstrual periods. Therefore, a woman is exposed to less estrogen and has decreased breast cancer risk. Breast-feeding also keeps breast tissue matured into Type 4 that decrease cancer risk. Breast feeding is known to decrease breast cancer risk in proportion to the total duration of breast feeding of all infants.
Metabolism refers to the way the body changes and
processes hormones and other chemicals. This process
also involves elimination of these chemicals from
the body. Most of the active
made by the ovaries is changed by the liver into an
inactive form, which does not cause the breast cells
to divide ().
But some estrogen is transformed into a long-acting
estrogen that continues to stimulate the breast cells
to divide. Some women's bodies produce higher levels
of this long-acting estrogen, and therefore have a
higher breast cancer risk.
However, some things we eat can affect estrogen metabolism.
For example, indole-3-carbinol, a substance found
in cruciferous vegetables, is converted to (diindolylmethane)
in the stomach. This causes greater production of
the inactive of estrogen, decreasing the
risk of breast cancer.
By inhibiting liver function, alcohol decreases the
body's ability to change estrogen into the inactive
form and therefore, increases risk.
Women have increased risk when their bodies create
more of the active metabolite of estrogen.
How we live our lives and the choices we make concerning what we consume, what habits we keep, how we control our fertility and decide if and when to have children, how much we exercise, and even how long we stay in school and our career choices all influence our risk of breast cancer.
Diet
Diets that are high in phytoestrogens, especially
as teenagers, can lower breast cancer risk. Phytoestrogens
are plant estrogens that can block our . These phytoestrogens do not stimulate
our breast cells to proliferate as much as our own
body's
do. Teenagers who eat soy products have lower breast
cancer rates. Phytoestrogens are found in many vegetables.
Indole-3-carbinol is found in cruciferous vegetables
such as cauliflower and broccoli. This chemical is
converted by the stomach to ,
which causes estrogen to be metabolized into an inactive
estrogen that does not stimulate breast tissue to
proliferate and thereby reduces breast cancer risk.
DIM is also widely available in pill form, as a nutritional
supplement.
Countries which have diets high in omega-3 fatty acids,
such as those found in deep water fish oils, have
populations which develop breast cancer at an older
age than countries with diets low in these oils. Olive
oil has been found to decrease breast cancer risk
in postmenopausal women. Canola, flax seed and walnut
oils are also rich in omega-3 fatty acids.
A diet too high in calories, which leads to obesity,
increases breast cancer risk. Postmenopausal obesity
increases breast cancer risk because the
enzyme system in fat cells causes more estrogen to
be formed. Children who are obese develop menstrual
cycles an early age, also increasing breast cancer
risk.
Drinking alcohol in any form, beer, wine or spirits, increases breast cancer risk through its effect upon the liver. The liver metabolizes estrogen and can change it into an inactive form. A liver impaired by alcohol lets estrogen build to higher levels, thereby stimulating the breast. For example, men who are alcoholics develop increased breast tissue, called gynecomastia, from elevated estrogen levels.
Lifestyle habits
Recent studies suggest that cigarette smoking before
having children-especially among teenagers-also increases
premenopausal breast cancer risk substantially.
Benzopyrenes in cigarette smoke act as direct
to cells lining the milk ducts.
Exercise is also important in reducing breast
cancer risk. Overall, moderate exercise can reduce
breast cancer risk by 30%. Exercise also can prevent
obesity, which increases breast cancer risk.
Exercise can delay the onset of a woman's first menstrual
cycle, menarche, which also decreases breast
cancer risk. Exercise may result in ,
and therefore, low-estrogen menstrual cycles, thus
decreasing risk.
The method a woman chooses to control her fertility
also greatly affects her breast cancer risk. While
synthetic steroid drugs in the form of birth control
pills, patches, vaginal rings, IUDs or injectable
progestins can increase breast cancer risk by up to
1,000%, as one study showed, the use of
(NFP) will not cause any increase
in breast cancer risk. Natural family planning teaches
a woman to reliably determine her fertile days by
recognizing her own bodily changes during her fertile
and infertile days of her menstrual cycle. Studies
have shown efficacy rates similar to those of "the
pill" without the cost and side effects. NFP
is NOT the "rhythm method" and can
be used effectively by women with regular or irregular
menstrual cycles. There are several NFP methods in
wide use, including the Billings Ovulatory Method,
and NaProTechnology, which is based on the Creighton
model. These methods are also used by women to overcome
infertility, thus avoiding the use of synthetic fertility
drugs such as Clomid.
The age at which a woman chooses to have children
also determines breast cancer risk. Compared to a
woman who gives birth at 30, a woman who has a full-term
pregnancy before age 20 has only one-third the risk
of breast cancer. By having children early in their
reproductive life, women can greatly reduce their
breast cancer risk. Women also avoid the risk of infertility,
which advancing age brings, by having children when
they are young. By avoiding infertility, a woman avoids
exposure to hormonal fertility drugs. Choosing to
end a pregnancy through an , especially
the first pregnancy as a teenager, significantly increases
breast cancer risk.
Breast feeding your children will also decrease breast
cancer risk. Breast feeding fully matures the breast
and often results in or missed cycles.
High socioeconomic status and a high level of education
are also presently associated with higher breast cancer
risk. Women, who have high socioeconomic status, more
commonly have children late in their reproductive
life or remain childless, well established risks for
breast cancer. Women who achieve high levels of education
through college and postgraduate levels also tend
to delay childbearing or remain childless. They commonly
accomplish this through hormonal birth control (contraceptive
steroids in pill, patch or injectable form). In 1975
only 10% of women between 40 and 45 were childless,
now it is 18% according to the US 2000 census data.
Making informed health care choices
Don't take hormones for conditions which are not necessarily
abnormal, such as irregular menstrual cycles in teenagers.
In fact, teenagers who do not experience regular menstrual
cycles until 5 years after , have a decreased
breast cancer risk compared to those who cycle regularly
right after menarche.
Don't take hormones for disease treatments for which
other non-hormonal treatments are equally effective.
Actonel, Fosamax, calcium supplements and exercise
can reduce osteoporosis without the need for estrogen.
(dehydroepiandrosterone), a normal metabolic
intermediate substance produced by the adrenal gland,
but which declines with age, is widely available as
a nutritional supplement. While not itself an active
hormone, DHEA can be converted to active hormones
by certain tissues. For example, it can be converted
to estrogen by bone and vaginal lining, but not uterine
lining. Thus it does not increase the risk of uterine
cancer, but it can prevent or reverse bone loss and
other menopausal symptoms. (DHEA cannot be converted
to testosterone by muscle tissue or cause an increase
in muscle mass.) Acne can be treated with antibiotics.
There are effective methods of birth control (such
as ) that do not rely on hormones. Menstrual cramps
can be treated with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
drugs such as ibuprophen.
| Factor | Mechanism |
| Alcohol | Increases
estrogen exposure by impairing liver function |
| Benign
proliferative breast disease
|
Result of increased estrogen exposure |
| BRCA genes | Inherited
defects in cancer defense genes |
| Cigarette smoking | Benzopyrenes damage DNA |
Contraceptive
steroids (in pills, patches, vaginal rings,
IUDs or injectable forms) |
Increases estrogen exposure |
| Early menarche | Increases estrogen exposure |
| Female sex | Increased estrogen exposure |
| High socio-economic group | Delayed childbearing |
| Higher education | Delayed childbearing |
Hormone
replacement therapy (HRT) |
Increases estrogen exposure |
| Increasing age |
Premenopausal: Increases
estrogen exposure Postmenopausal: Impairs immune function |
| Induced abortion | Leaves
increased number of immature breast lobules
and increases risk of premature births Increases estrogen exposure |
| Late childbirth (over 30 years old) | Increases
exposure of Type 1 & 2
lobulesto estrogen before first birth; long susceptibility
window |
| Late menopause | Increases estrogen exposure |
|
Nulliparity
(never bearing children) |
Maturity
of breast lobules does not occur |
| Premature birth before 32 weeks | Leaves
increased number of immature breast lobules Increases estrogen exposure |
| Postmenopausal obesity | Increases estrogen exposure |
| Radiation | Damages DNA |
| 2nd trimester miscarriage | Leaves
increased number of immature breast lobules |
| Factor | Mechanism |
|
Breast feeding
|
Decreases estrogen
by decreasing number of menstrual cycles
and/or ovulation
|
|
Cruciferous
vegetables (e.g., broccoli, Brussels sprouts
or DIM supplements)
|
Indole-3-carbinol
decreases estrogen exposure by causing estrogen
to be changed to an inactive metabolite
of estrogen
|
|
Early
menopause
|
Decreases estrogen
exposure
|
|
Exercise
|
Decreases estrogen
exposure
|
|
Having children
(especially starting at a young age)
|
Decreases number
of immature breast lobules
|
| Late menarche | Decreases estrogen exposure |
|
Omega-3 fatty
acids (e.g., olive, flax seed, walnut oils)
|
Unknown |
|
Oophorectomy
(removal of ovaries before menopause)
|
Decreases estrogen production |
|
Soy isoflavonoids
(phytoestrogens)
|
May block estrogen receptors |
| Factor | Reason |
| Saturated fat |
Saturated
fat intake not related to obesity
|
|
Spontaneous
abortions
(miscarriages) in the first trimester |
No increased
levels of estrogen as found in healthy
pregnancies
|
Eat cruciferous vegetables
The cruciferous vegetables (e.g., broccoli, Brussels
sprouts, cauliflower, watercress, kale and cabbage)
contain high levels of indole-3-carbinol. This chemical,
which is changed to in the stomach, causes the
liver to form more of the inactive metabolite of estrogen,
thereby reducing estrogen exposure. DIM can also be
taken as a nutritional supplement.
Eat Omega-3 fatty acids
These essential fatty acids are found in fish and
many vegetable oils. Postmenopausal women who eat
olive oil daily reduce their risk of breast cancer
by 25%. Vegetable oils rich in omega-3 fatty acids
include canola, flax seed, walnut and olive oils.
Eat soy products and vegetables
with phytoestrogens
One study suggests that teenage girls who eat soy
products may lower their risk of breast cancer later
in life. Soybeans contain “phytoestrogens”
which decrease the activity of produced by
the ovaries. Other vegetables also contain phytoestrogens.
Limit alcoholic beverages
The more alcohol you drink, the higher your risk of
breast cancer. Occasional alcoholic drinks will not
increase your risk; however, regularly drinking alcohol
every day will.
Reduce your exposure to estrogen
Avoid steroidal hormone therapies for contraception
to minimize breast cancer risk. These include birth
control pills and patches, and injectable or implantable
hormones. Methods of fertility regulation that do
not increase breast cancer risks can be used; for
example, .
Avoid prolonged hormone replacement therapy (HRT)
for (around ) and postmenopausal
symptoms to minimize breast cancer risk. There is
no proven benefit to the heart with
HRT. In fact, there is very strong recent evidence
that HRT actually increases the risk of heart disease,
stroke and dementia. There are other medications available,
such as Fosomax and Actonel which can increase bone
density for the treatment and prevention of osteoporosis.
The nutritional supplement can also increase
bone density and ameliorate other menopausal symptoms.
Don't smoke!
Benzopyrenes—the known carcinogens in tobacco
smoke—damage DNA and increase
the risk of breast, bladder, cervical and lung cancer.
Exercise
One to three hours of exercise a week can reduce your
breast cancer risk by 30%. Women who train strenuously
may lose their menstrual cycle or become anovulatory,
and therefore be exposed to far less . Exercise
can also delay the onset of .
Maintain normal body weight
Obesity after menopause increases breast cancer risk
because fat (adipose) cells manufacture estrogen.
Obesity may cause early menarche.
Have children earlier in life
Having children in the early twenties or as a teenager
decreases risk. Delaying child bearing until after
30 increases the risk of breast cancer substantially.
Breast feed your children
Breast feeding is known to decrease breast cancer
risk in proportion to the total duration of breast
feeding of all infants.
Avoid induced abortions
Having an , especially as a teenager
or before you have a full-term pregnancy, increases
risk. If you do have an abortion, taking contraceptive
steroids (e.g., “the pill”) after an abortion
will increase risk further. However, subsequently
having children and breast-feeding them will reduce
the risk. Induced abortions also increase the risk
of premature delivery and very premature delivery
(before 32 weeks) in subsequent pregnancies. Since
most breast lobules are not matured until after 32
weeks gestation, very premature delivery also increases
breast cancer risk, as well increasing the risk of
cerebral palsy in the newborn. There are organizations
which specialize in the placement of Down’s
Syndrome babies with families that welcome these infants
if the mother is not able to care for a special needs
child herself
Avoid induced premature deliveries
Sometimes women are counseled to end the pregnancy when there is a fetal abnormality not compatible with life after birth by having her labor induced prematurely. However, by carrying that child to term, such as an anencephalic infant, the mother will gain protection against breast cancer. There are perinatal hospices for the child after birth.
Make informed health care choices
Use non-hormonal therapies when available to treat
osteoporosis, acne or painful periods. Use for birth control instead of
birth control pills, patches or injections.
There are many ways women can reduce their risk of breast cancer through the avoidance of unnecessary hormones and drugs and through dietary and lifestyle changes.
Finding breast cancers by mammogram when they are small does increase breast cancer survival. Smaller tumors are usually more differentiated and are less likely to have spread to lymph nodes.
|